15 Mins read

Differences between Comprehensive and TLO Car Insurance

Oona

Oona

Comprehensive (All Risk) vs. TLO car insurance

Choosing the right car insurance is essential to protect your vehicle from financial loss. In Indonesia, the two most common types of car insurance are Comprehensive Insurance (All Risk) and Total Loss Only (TLO) Insurance. The main difference between these two policies is their coverage. Comprehensive insurance covers both minor and major damages, while TLO insurance only provides compensation for total loss (damage exceeding 75% of the car’s value) or theft.

What is Car Insurance?

Car insurance is a financial product that provides protection against vehicle-related risks, such as accidents, theft, natural disasters, and other damages. It helps car owners cover repair or replacement costs, reducing the financial burden when unexpected events occur.

Why is Car Insurance Important in Indonesia?

Indonesia has high traffic congestion, frequent road accidents, and natural disaster risks, making car insurance an essential safeguard. Here are some key reasons why car insurance is necessary:
 

  • Protection from accidents – Covers repair costs if your vehicle is damaged in a collision.
     

  • Financial security – Prevents out-of-pocket expenses for unexpected car repairs or replacements.
     

  • Theft coverage – Essential in cities where vehicle theft is a common concern.
     

  • Natural disaster protection – Provides compensation for damages due to floods, earthquakes, or landslides.
     

  • Peace of mind – Helps car owners feel secure while driving.
     

In Indonesia, car insurance is available in two main types: Comprehensive Insurance and TLO Insurance. Let's explore their differences.

What is Comprehensive Car Insurance?

Comprehensive insurance, also known as All Risk insurance, provides extensive coverage that protects your vehicle against both minor and major damages.

Coverage of Comprehensive Insurance:

  • Minor & major damages: Covers scratches, dents, broken side mirrors, and severe damages from accidents.

  • Accidents & collisions: Covers repair or replacement costs due to accidents.

  • Natural disasters: Protects against floods, earthquakes, and landslides, which are common risks in Indonesia.

  • Fire & theft: Covers damages caused by fire and losses due to car theft.

  • Vandalism & riots: Provides financial protection if your car is damaged due to riots or intentional damage.

  • Third-party liability (optional add-on): Covers expenses if your car damages another person’s vehicle or property.


In Indonesia, Comprehensive insurance is highly recommended for new or high-value cars, especially for those frequently driven in cities like Jakarta, Surabaya, or Bandung, where traffic congestion and accident risks are high.


However, Comprehensive insurance premiums are higher than TLO due to its broad coverage.

What is Total Loss Only (TLO) Car Insurance?

Total Loss Only (TLO) insurance only provides compensation if the vehicle is completely lost or severely damaged (above 75% of its value).

Coverage of TLO Insurance:

  • Total loss due to accidents: Covers damage where repair costs exceed 75% of the car’s market value.

  • Theft protection: Provides financial compensation if the car is stolen.

  • Fire incidents: Covers total loss due to fire.

  • Natural disasters & riots (optional add-on): Some policies offer extra protection for floods, earthquakes, and riots.


TLO insurance is more affordable than Comprehensive insurance and is ideal for older vehicles or car owners looking for budget-friendly protection. However, it does not cover minor damages like scratches, dents, or broken mirrors.

Key Differences Between Comprehensive and TLO Insurance

Differences between All Risk and TLO car insurance

Choose Comprehensive Insurance If:

  • You own a new or high-value car that needs full protection.

  • You want coverage for both minor and major damages.

  • You frequently drive in high-traffic areas with a higher accident risk.

  • You want additional protection against theft, fire, and third-party liability.

Choose TLO Insurance If:

  • You have an older car with a lower market value.

  • You prefer lower premiums and only need protection for total loss.

  • You don’t mind covering minor repairs out of pocket.

  • Your car is rarely used or parked in a secure location.

Conclusion

Both Comprehensive and TLO insurance have their advantages, depending on your vehicle type, usage, and budget. If you want full protection against both minor and major damages, Comprehensive insurance is the better choice. However, if you're looking for affordable protection and only need coverage for total loss, TLO insurance is the right option.
 

Before purchasing car insurance, consider the driving risks in Indonesia, such as high traffic congestion, frequent natural disasters, and vehicle theft rates in different regions.
 

Protect your car with the right insurance plan. Whether you need Comprehensive or TLO coverage, Oona offers flexible and affordable car insurance options tailored to your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are there other types of car insurance?

Answer

Yes, All Risk insurance covers all types of damages but with higher premiums.

Questions
Are there other types of car insurance?
Sequence Id
4
Tags

Why is it important to understand TPL and TLO differences?

Answer

Knowing the difference helps you choose the right coverage that fits your needs, budget, and driving risks.

Questions
Why is it important to understand TPL and TLO differences?
Sequence Id
6
Tags

What is Third Party Liability (TPL)?

Answer

TPL protects against damages or injuries you cause to third parties, including their vehicles or property.

Questions
What is Third Party Liability (TPL)?
Sequence Id
1
Tags

Which is better, TPL or TLO?

Answer

It depends on your needs. TPL is better for high-risk drivers in busy areas, while TLO is ideal for older cars or lower-risk drivers.

Questions
Which is better, TPL or TLO?
Sequence Id
3
Tags

What is Total Loss Only (TLO)?

Answer

TLO covers total losses, such as theft or severe damage, but does not cover minor damages.

Questions
What is Total Loss Only (TLO)?
Sequence Id
2
Tags

Is TPL the most affordable option?

Answer

Yes, TPL is often the most affordable for drivers who want basic protection in densely populated or high-traffic areas.

Questions
Is TPL the most affordable option?
Sequence Id
5
Tags

Dapatkan Asuransi Mobil dari Oona Sekarang!

Get Free Quote